A Book by Shlomo Sand Calls Jewish People an ‘Invention’

 

Book Calls Jewish People an ‘Invention’

By PATRICIA COHEN

Despite the fragmented and incomplete historical record, experts pretty much agree that some popular beliefs about Jewish history simply don’t hold up: there was no sudden expulsion of all Jews from Jerusalem in A.D. 70, for instance. What’s more, modern Jews owe their ancestry as much to converts from the first millennium and early Middle Ages as to the Jews of antiquity.

Skip to next paragraph

Enlarge This Image

Rina Castelnuovo for The New York Times

Professor Shlomo Sand of Tel Aviv University, whose latest book is rekindling an old debate.

Video of Sand’s Lectures (inventionofthejewishpeople.com)

Other theories, like the notion that many of today’s Palestinians can legitimately claim to be descended from the ancient Jews, are familiar and serious subjects of study, even if no definitive answer yet exists.

But while these ideas are commonplace among historians, they still manage to provoke controversy each time they surface in public, beyond the scholarly world. The latest example is the book “The Invention of the Jewish People,” which spent months on the best-seller list in Israel and is now available in English. Mixing respected scholarship with dubious theories, the author, Shlomo Sand, a professor at Tel Aviv University, frames the narrative as a startling exposure of suppressed historical facts. The translated version of his polemic has sparked a new wave of coverage in Britain and has provoked spirited debates online and in seminar rooms.

Professor Sand, a scholar of modern France, not Jewish history, candidly states his aim is to undercut the Jews’ claims to the land of Israel by demonstrating that they do not constitute “a people,” with a shared racial or biological past. The book has been extravagantly denounced and praised, often on the basis of whether or not the reader agrees with his politics.

The vehement response to these familiar arguments — both the reasonable and the outrageous — highlights the challenge of disentangling historical fact from the sticky web of religious and political myth and memory.

Consider, for instance, Professor Sand’s assertion that Palestinian Arab villagers are descended from the original Jewish farmers. Nearly a century ago, early Zionists and Arab nationalists touted the blood relationship as the basis of a potential alliance in their respective struggles for independence. Israel’s first prime minister, David Ben-Gurion, and Yitzhak Ben Zvi, Israel’s longest-serving president, made this very argument in a book they wrote together in 1918. The next year, Emir Feisal, who organized the Arab revolt against the Ottoman empire and tried to create a united Arab nation, signed a cooperation agreement with the Zionist leader Chaim Weizmann that declared the two were “mindful of the racial kinship and ancient bonds existing between the Arabs and the Jewish people.”

Both sides later dropped the subject when they realized it was not furthering their political goals.

(Though no final consensus has emerged on the ancestral link between Palestinians and Jews, Harry Ostrer, director of the Human Genetics Program at New York University Langone Medical Center, who has been studying the genetic organization of Jews, said, “The assumption of lineal descent seems reasonable.”)

Books challenging biblical and conventional history continually pop up, but what distinguishes the dispute over origins from debates about, say, the reality of the exodus from Egypt or the historical Jesus, is that it is so enmeshed in geopolitics. The Israeli Declaration of Independence states: “After being forcibly exiled from their Land, the People kept faith with it throughout their Dispersion and never ceased to pray and hope for their return to it.” The idea of unjust exile and rightful return undergirds both the Jews’ and the Palestinians’ conviction that each is entitled to the land.

Since Professor Sand’s mission is to discredit Jews’ historical claims to the territory, he is keen to show that their ancestry lines do not lead back to ancient Palestine. He resurrects a theory first raised by 19th-century historians, that the Jews of Central and Eastern Europe, to whom 90 percent of American Jews trace their roots, are descended from the Khazars, a Turkic people who apparently converted to Judaism and created an empire in the Caucasus in the eighth century. This idea has long intrigued writers and historians. In 1976, Arthur Koestler wrote “The Thirteenth Tribe” in the hopes it would combat anti-Semitism; if contemporary Jews were descended from the Khazars, he argued, they could not be held responsible for Jesus’ Crucifixion.

By now, experts who specialize in the subject have repeatedly rejected the theory, concluding that the shards of evidence are inconclusive or misleading, said Michael Terry, the chief librarian of the Jewish division of the New York Public Library. Dr. Ostrer said the genetics also did not support the Khazar theory.

That does not negate that conversion played a critical role in Jewish history — a proposition that many find surprising given that today’s Jews tend to discourage conversion and make it a difficult process. Lawrence H. Schiffman, chairman of the Skirball department of Hebrew and Judaic Studies at New York University, said most historians agree that over a period of centuries, Middle Eastern Jews — merchants, slaves and captives, religious and economic refugees — spread around the world. Many intermarried with people from local populations, who then converted.

  • 1
  • 2

Next Page »

A Book by Shlomo Sand Calls Jewish People an ‘Invention’ – NYTimes.com

 

 

 

Technorati Tags: ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

Windows Live Tags: Book,Shlomo,Sand,Jewish,People,Invention,PATRICIA,COHEN,Despite,beliefs,history,expulsion,Jews,Jerusalem,instance,ancestry,Middle,Skip,paragraph,Enlarge,Image,Rina,Castelnuovo,York,Times,Professor,Aviv,Video,notion,Palestinians,ideas,controversy,world,example,seller,Israel,English,scholarship,author,narrative,exposure,version,coverage,Britain,seminar,rooms,scholar,France,basis,reader,politics,response,arguments,highlights,fact,myth,memory,Consider,assertion,Palestinian,Arab,Zionists,relationship,alliance,independence,David,Gurion,Yitzhak,president,argument,Emir,Feisal,Ottoman,empire,nation,cooperation,agreement,Zionist,leader,Chaim,Weizmann,kinship,Arabs,Both,subject,Though,consensus,Harry,Ostrer,director,Human,Genetics,Program,Medical,Center,organization,assumption,origins,exodus,Egypt,Jesus,Israeli,Declaration,Land,faith,Dispersion,conviction,mission,territory,Palestine,theory,Central,Eastern,Europe,American,roots,Khazars,Turkic,Judaism,Caucasus,Arthur,Koestler,Thirteenth,Tribe,Semitism,Crucifixion,shards,Michael,Terry,Public,Library,Khazar,conversion,role,proposition,Lawrence,Schiffman,Skirball,department,Hebrew,Judaic,period,Many,Page,NYTimes,theories,subjects,goals,refugees,historians,century

WordPress Tags: Book,Shlomo,Sand,Jewish,People,Invention,PATRICIA,COHEN,Despite,beliefs,history,expulsion,Jews,Jerusalem,instance,ancestry,Middle,Skip,paragraph,Enlarge,Image,Rina,Castelnuovo,York,Times,Professor,Aviv,Video,notion,Palestinians,ideas,controversy,world,example,seller,Israel,English,scholarship,author,narrative,exposure,version,coverage,Britain,seminar,rooms,scholar,France,basis,reader,politics,response,arguments,highlights,fact,myth,memory,Consider,assertion,Palestinian,Arab,Zionists,relationship,alliance,independence,David,Gurion,Yitzhak,president,argument,Emir,Feisal,Ottoman,empire,nation,cooperation,agreement,Zionist,leader,Chaim,Weizmann,kinship,Arabs,Both,subject,Though,consensus,Harry,Ostrer,director,Human,Genetics,Program,Medical,Center,organization,assumption,origins,exodus,Egypt,Jesus,Israeli,Declaration,Land,faith,Dispersion,conviction,mission,territory,Palestine,theory,Central,Eastern,Europe,American,roots,Khazars,Turkic,Judaism,Caucasus,Arthur,Koestler,Thirteenth,Tribe,Semitism,Crucifixion,shards,Michael,Terry,Public,Library,Khazar,conversion,role,proposition,Lawrence,Schiffman,Skirball,department,Hebrew,Judaic,period,Many,Page,NYTimes,theories,subjects,goals,refugees,historians,century

Blogger Labels: Book,Shlomo,Sand,Jewish,People,Invention,PATRICIA,COHEN,Despite,beliefs,history,expulsion,Jews,Jerusalem,instance,ancestry,Middle,Skip,paragraph,Enlarge,Image,Rina,Castelnuovo,York,Times,Professor,Aviv,Video,notion,Palestinians,ideas,controversy,world,example,seller,Israel,English,scholarship,author,narrative,exposure,version,coverage,Britain,seminar,rooms,scholar,France,basis,reader,politics,response,arguments,highlights,fact,myth,memory,Consider,assertion,Palestinian,Arab,Zionists,relationship,alliance,independence,David,Gurion,Yitzhak,president,argument,Emir,Feisal,Ottoman,empire,nation,cooperation,agreement,Zionist,leader,Chaim,Weizmann,kinship,Arabs,Both,subject,Though,consensus,Harry,Ostrer,director,Human,Genetics,Program,Medical,Center,organization,assumption,origins,exodus,Egypt,Jesus,Israeli,Declaration,Land,faith,Dispersion,conviction,mission,territory,Palestine,theory,Central,Eastern,Europe,American,roots,Khazars,Turkic,Judaism,Caucasus,Arthur,Koestler,Thirteenth,Tribe,Semitism,Crucifixion,shards,Michael,Terry,Public,Library,Khazar,conversion,role,proposition,Lawrence,Schiffman,Skirball,department,Hebrew,Judaic,period,Many,Page,NYTimes,theories,subjects,goals,refugees,historians,century

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Things to Know. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s